The grounds for the German Federal Court of Justice's decision in the Sparkassen Group/Banco Santander dispute over the validity of Sparkassen's colour mark "red" (HSK 13) for financial services, namely retail banking, have been published last week. The 46-page judgment takes a very close look at the proper methodology of consumer surveys designed to prove acquired distinctiveness. Since no less than four surveys were submitted by the parties, two by each side, the Court had a wealth of material to work with.
|
Red. |
If you are not familiar with the background of the dispute, have a look at our
earlier post on the decision. Essentially, Banco Santander applied for a declaration of invalidity for lack of (acquired) distinctiveness of Sparkassen's colour mark, was unsuccessful before the German IPO, successful before the Federal Patent Court and ultimately unsuccessful before the Bundesgerichtshof, which confirmed the validity of the mark. The case led to a referral to the CJEU, which was answered in the joined cases
C‑217/13 and C‑218/13 in 2014 (see
summary by Birgit Clark on IPKat).
Given the length of the decision, I can only highlight a few points in the following. The decision will be the reference case for the design of consumer surveys for proof of acquired distinctiveness for years to come.
The
IPSOS survey from 2006 showed the participants a red card and opened with the following question:
Have you ever seen this colour in connection with financial institutions, or does it appear familiar in this context? Or have you never encountered this colour in connection with financial institutions?
According to the BGH, this question was suggestive, as it already created a link to a certain kind of companies, namely financial institutions. It already introduced the key question - whether the sign was understood as reference to a single entity - into the first question, which should only filter for persons that have never encountered the sign (para. 43). The proper way was to ask whether the respondents had seen the colour in connection with the claimed
products.
A further "grave flaw" of the IPSOS survey was counting those respondents that said that they had never encountered the sign among the 66% of respondents that associated the sign with the Sparkassen Group. Those respondents who do not recall ever having seen the sign must be counted among those who do not perceive the sign as an indication of source (para. 45). The
Pflüger survey submitted by Sparkassen Group in 2013 was not able to correct the deficiencies of the IPSOS survey from 2006. Surveys conducted several years after the relevant date - here the trade mark owner tried to prove acquired distinctiveness at the time of filing in 2002 - could only be considered if the market conditions were stable over longer periods of time, which was not established here (para. 50).
|
Too much paper... |
Another flaw of the Pflüger survey - which equally applies to the IPSOS survey - was that the first question asked "Have you ever seen this colour in connection with financial services [as listed]
or does it appear familiar in this context? Or have you never encountered this colour in this context?" According to the Court, the part of the question here put in italics is impermissible, as it leads respondents to consider a third answer, other than yes or no, to the question. It was fine to count those who
spontaneously answered that the colour appeared familiar among those who know the sign, but "looks familiar" must not be an explicit option, as it leads to inflated figures (para. 72. In the case at hand, only about 17% of respondents spontaneously answer that the colour seems familiar, but 24% if explicitly given the option).
The Court addressed, but left deliberately open, the allocation of the burden of proof. According to German case law, if
lack of acquired distinctiveness at the time of filing cannot be established, the validity of the mark is confirmed, so the burden of proof lies with the nullity plaintiff. According to the CJEU's judgment in cases C-217/13 and C-218/13, the opposite is true - the burden of proof for acquired distinctiveness lies with the trade mark owner (
there at para. 68). The BGH did not have to decide the issue - it hints that it is unhappy with the CJEU's finding - because it found that the evidence on record established that the mark had acquired distinctiveness at the time of the Federal Patent Court's decision in 2015. Because Germany exercised the option under Article 3(3) second sentence
Directive 2008/95, proof of acquired distinctiveness either at the time of filing or at the time of decision leads to validity of the mark (§
8(3) German Trade Mark Act).
The respondents in the Pflüger survey answered the second question as follows:
In connection with financial services...
- the colour refers to ("hinweisen") a specific financial institution (63%)
- the colour refers to several financial institutions (8%)
- the colour does not refer to any financial institution (4%)
- cannot answer (6%)
This question was appropriate (para. 79). 62% of respondents named a company of the trade mark owner's group in answer to the third question "Do you know the name of this financial instution?".
Overall, the Bundesgerichtshof considered that the survey, flawed as it was, proved that more than 50% of the relevant consumers perceived the colour as a reference to a specific financial institution, i.e. as distinctive. Although the Court repeats the old "there cannot be fixed percentage values as absolute limits" (para. 92), it is pretty clear that anything above 50% is enough (para. 109).
Also interesting is what the Court did
not address with a single word - whether it is enough that the consumers
perceive the colour as a reference to a single entity, or whether it must be demonstrated that they
rely on the mark when choosing the product. As you may recall, Arnold J in his second KitKat decision (
IPKat post) held that "the applicant or trade mark proprietor must prove that, at the relevant date, a significant proportion of the relevant class of persons perceives the relevant goods or services as originating from a particular undertaking
because of the sign in question" (
there at para. 57) and considered the survey evidence submitted by Nestlé, structurally very similar to the evidence before the Federal Court of Justice, to be inadequate to answer this question. Since the briefs are not on public record in Germany, it is unclear whether the nullity plaintiff even raised the issue. In any case, German Courts do not seem to be inclined to follow Arnold J's lead (for a critical take on the KitKat decision, see my
recent piece in ABA's Landslide Magazine).
BalasHapusdrivers license
buy id cards
where to buy id cards lchs
buy real id cards online
diploma,birth certificate
buy fake real counterfeit money passports
buy cbd oil online for pain
where to buy real cbd oil with thc online
can you vape the cbd oil you buy online
buy hemplucid cbd oil online
can you buy cbd oil online in ohio
buy cbd thc oil online dispenserie
buy cbd oil online amazon
buy cbd oil online in iowa
cbd oil with thc can i buy online?
where can i buy kronic tonic cbd oil online
is cbd oil safe to buy online
mephedrone plant food buy online
ethylone drug
buy green card
where can you buy a counterfeit money pen
what can i buy to check for counterfeit money
can a green card holder buy a gun
where to buy green dot card
where to buy outboard motors in rhode island
where can i buy outboard motors
buy refurbished outboard motors near me
buy ethylone
where can i buy good cbd oil online
can you buy hemp cbd oil online
highest rated online sites to buy cbd oil
can you buy cbd oil online ny
buy cw hemp cbd oil online
best place to buy cbd vape oil online reddit
moon lion cbd oil buy online
buy tpe sex doll
BalasHapussex with dolls
best sex dolls
2-oxo-pce
1p-lsd us
male sex doll
sex dolls for men
can you buy new florida drivers license online
buy online a replacement ms drivers license
buy fake drivers license online from china
buy german drivers license online
small sex dolls
teen sex doll
buy real counterfeit money online
can you buy counterfeit money online
where to buy counterfeit money online
dank vapes new packaging
dank vapes sweet aromatic
how much thc does dank vapes have
dank vapes safe
dank vapes white rhino fake
dank vapes lemon cookies
dank vapes zkittlez strain
dank vapes og
dank vapes products
which dank vapes are the best
we buy catalytic converters chicago
we buy catalytic converters miami
buy wholesale catalytic converters
where do they buy catalytic converters in abq
buy outboard motors from china
how to use dank vapes
dank vapes los angeles confidential 420.710
does dank vapes have pesticides
dank vapes lemon head
teen sex doll
small sex doll
BalasHapusBuy smart Carts
order smart carts online
smart carts for sale Online
Purchase smart carts Online
Order smart buds Online
Buy dankwoods online
dankwoods for sale Online
order dankwoods online
Purchase dankwoods Online
Order dankwoods Online
Top Work From Home Online Business Ideas
BalasHapusPowerful Online Business Marketing
BalasHapusHow Blog Marketing Impacts Your Small Business
BalasHapuseasycareshop
BalasHapuseasycareshop is the newest development, serving clients online with their pharmaceutical needs. Our retail outlets are supported by an efficient Headquarter team based in United States.
Buy xanax online
BalasHapusXanax belongs to the benzodiazepines drug, which is using to address anxiety, panic disorder, and stress by stimulating the disturbed and unbalanced chemicals in the brain. Xanax offers calming effects in the brain to enhance the productivity level.Butor’s consultation and guidelines.
I love to study this sort of post and articles. It is great way to learn and understand. Nice Job!.Female escorts in Mumbai
BalasHapusMumbai female escorts
Welcome to the best online Satta King India Game that you can play from
BalasHapusany where and its safe. Aram se ghr baithe apne phone pe khelo disawar/satta King. gurgaon razz satta king, satta king
india, satta king india com, sattaking, raja rani sattaking, india satta king, satta king indian, gali satta king, satta
result 2020.gurgaon razz sattaking, satta king india.com, satta king india, india satta king, satta king sadabad,
sattakingindia, all india satta king, all india satta result, sattaking, sattakingindia, raja rani satta king, satta king
india com, indian satta king, satta king indian, Satta King, satta king of
india, satta india.com, ranisatta king, sadabad satta king, satta king all india, all india satta king result, sadabad
satta,satta.com india, india satta.com, satta rani king, india satta, satta king rani, raja rani satta result, india all
satta result, india gate satta king, all india satta, all india satta results,satta king india result.
Contact The Social Bear Digital Marketing Agency for more organic
traffic.
Digital Marketing Agency USA
Satta King India offering you to play online. Get your number, wait for lucky draw, may today is turn to become a millioner. Aram se ghr baithe apne phone pe khelo disawar/satta King. gurgaon razz satta king, satta king india, satta king india com, Satta King, sattaking, raja rani sattaking, india satta king, satta king indian, gali satta king, satta result 2020.gurgaon razz sattaking, सट्टा किंग , satta king india.com, satta king india, india satta king, satta king sadabad, sattakingindia, all india satta king, all india satta result, sattaking, sattakingindia, raja rani satta king, satta king india com, indian satta king, satta king indian, Satta King, satta king of india, satta india.com, ranisatta king, sadabad satta king, satta king all india, all india satta king result, sadabad satta,satta.com india, india satta.com, satta rani king, india satta, satta king rani, raja rani satta result, india all satta result, india gate satta king, all india satta, all india satta results,satta king india result.
BalasHapuscontact The Social Bear Digital Marketing Agency for more organic traffic.
Digital Marketing Agency USA
BalasHapuscomprare patente
rijbewijs kopen
rijbewijs kopen
comprar carta
buy driver licence
-PANDUAN PKVGAMES-
BalasHapusTIPS UNTUK MENDAPATKAN KEMENANGAN DENGAN SANGAT MUDAH DAN BERUNTUN
CARA UNTUK MENDAPATKAN JACKPOT SITUS JUDI ONLINE
rijbewijs kopen diensten
BalasHapusrijbewijs kopen belgie | geregistreerd rijbewijs kopen | rijbewijs kopen legaal | rijbewijs kopen nederland | rijbewijs online kopen | rijbewijs kopen | koop een rijbewijs | rijbewijs kopen in nederland | motor rijbewijs kopen | auto rijbewijs kopen | rijbewijs b kopen | rijbewijs kopen 2021
BalasHapusrijbewijs kopen legaal
| comprar carta de conducao |comprar carta de conduçao | comprar cartas de condução | comprar carta de condução |comprar carta de condução portuguesa | comprar carta de condução portugal |
comprar carta de condução legal | carta conducao portugal |carta de condução categoria | carta de condução d |carta de condução online |carta de condução portugal |carta de condução portugal preço |carta de condução portuguesa | cartas de condução categorias | cartas de condução portugal | carteira de conducao portuguesa | carteira de habilitação portugal | categoria de carta de condução
The Great blogs
köp körkort
Comprar licencia de conducir
acheter un permis de conduire
comprar carta de condução
buy ielts without exam
rijbewijs kopen